HireRight is strict about one comparison: whether the records it pulls match what you entered. How much that costs you depends on the package your employer ordered and the standard it applies, and HireRight sets neither.
What the employer's package decides
HireRight sells screening as separate services, and the employer picks which ones run. Its criminal page says what appears "depends on the searches selected by the employer," and no single check covers records everywhere. A package can stop at county searches, add statewide and federal searches, or add Widescreen Plus, which looks outside your known addresses.
| Check | Compared against |
|---|---|
| County, statewide and federal criminal searches | Court records for your name, date of birth and address history |
| Employment Verification | Dates, title and positions, confirmed with the employer |
| Education Verification | Dates and the degree awarded, confirmed with the institution |
What HireRight compares, and what it takes from your entries
Criminal searches start from your data. For a county search HireRight asks for your name, date of birth and address, and says that information "is typically provided by the candidate." The search runs against court records and state repositories, so a case you never mentioned can surface.
Verification works the other way. Employment Verification confirms your dates, title and positions with the employer, and HireRight notes candidates can supply "different employment dates or roles." Education Verification confirms dates and the degree awarded. Your entry is the benchmark, so a wrong month reads as a discrepancy even when the job was real.
HireRight's guide says 84% of employers in its survey found a misrepresentation, including "mistakenly listing incorrect employment dates."
Who decides whether a discrepancy fails you
HireRight says it "does not make hiring recommendations or decisions." Its guide says the employer decides which checks run and that one candidate's assessment "will be entirely different" from another's. A record is not automatic: "not every record would disqualify an applicant."
Before adverse action, the FTC and EEOC say the employer must give you a copy of the report and a summary of your rights, to explain anything negative. Afterward, the notice must name the reporting company and your right to a free copy within 60 days.
The EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records in October 2026 and said employers need not abandon practices adopted under it. Title VII still bars race and national origin discrimination, so state law and employer policy carry the weight.
If the report is wrong, dispute it free with HireRight; reinvestigation can take up to 30 days. For context on the decision, contact the employer, as HireRight directs.
What candidates report about small date differences
Reports vary because the standard does. In r/careerguidance, a candidate who added "about two extra months" to a past job said HireRight asked for the work contract; a commenter said it may be "a yellow flag which the HR might ignore." In r/recruitinghell, a candidate who stretched dates by five months was asked for a W2. In r/managers, a hiring manager said HR ended an offer after a candidate padded two jobs to close a one-year gap.
Each went to the employer, who chose. HireRight publishes no tolerance for a one-month or two-month difference.
How hiring teams should set the standard
Decide before the check runs which services each role needs, what counts as a material discrepancy, and who reviews it. Apply the rule to every candidate, as the FTC and EEOC instruct. A two-month gap on a job the person held should be a question, and a Widescreen Plus lead should be checked at the source court.
A HireRight report is one input in AI Candidate Evaluation, and the written standard keeps a date typo from carrying the same weight as a felony.